SEO Audit Example: A Sample Local Audit and How to Read It
This SEO audit example walks through a local audit of a sample HVAC company in Columbus, Ohio. The company is fictional, and so are its findings: they are typical problems we see in local audits, written out so you can see what a good audit looks like and how to read one. A local SEO audit checks the places Google looks when it decides who to show for a search like 'furnace repair near me': the Google Business Profile, reviews, citations, the website and the tracking behind it. A good audit does not list fifty small issues. It ranks the findings so you know what to fix first. Use the sample below as a template when you review your own business, or when you read an audit someone else sends you.
The sample business and what the audit looks at
The sample is a small HVAC company in Columbus, Ohio with one location, a few technicians and a website a former employee built. The audit covers five areas: Google Business Profile, reviews, citations, website and tracking. Each finding gets a reason it matters and a fix.
Every finding in this example is invented for teaching. Real audits start from the actual profile, the actual map results for the searches that matter, and the actual site. The structure, though, is the same each time.
The searches we would check for this company: 'hvac repair Columbus', 'furnace repair near me', 'AC installation Columbus OH'. We would look at who shows up in the map pack and what those profiles have that this one lacks.
SEO audit example: the findings table
The table lists eight typical findings across the five areas. Read each row the same way: what was found, why it matters, and what to do. The profile and reviews usually affect the map pack most, while the website and tracking decide how much that visibility turns into calls.
These are the patterns we see most often in local audits of trades businesses.
| Area | Sample finding | Why it matters | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Business Profile | Primary category is a general one; no secondary categories; service areas list only the home city | Categories drive which searches the profile qualifies for | Switch to the most specific primary category and add relevant secondary ones; add the real service areas |
| Google Business Profile | Services list is empty; description is two generic sentences; few photos, none of recent jobs | Empty fields give Google and customers little to match | Add each service with a plain description; upload real photos of installs and crews |
| Reviews | Reviews slowed to a trickle; several recent reviews have no owner reply | Recency and replies are visible trust signals | Ask every finished job for a review with a direct link; reply to all reviews within a few days |
| Citations | Old phone number on two directories; suite number missing on a third | Conflicting details make it harder for Google to trust the listing | Correct the aggregators first, then the directories that did not update |
| Website | One generic services page; no page for furnace repair or AC installation; city appears only in the footer | Google needs a page that matches each service and area | Build one page per core service, with local proof and the service area stated plainly |
| Website | Title tags read like 'Home | Company Name'; no local business schema | Title tags and structured data help Google read the page | Rewrite titles around service plus city; add LocalBusiness schema that matches the profile |
| Mobile and speed | Phone number is text, not a tap-to-call link; hero image loads slowly on a phone | Most local searches happen on a phone | Make the number tappable; compress images |
| Tracking | No call tracking; Search Console not connected | Without tracking you cannot tell what is working | Connect Search Console and the Google Business Profile Performance report; add call tracking if budget allows |
How to read an SEO audit without getting lost
Sort the findings into three groups: things that block you (wrong category, suspended or unverified profile, wrong phone number), things that hold you back (thin pages, few reviews) and things that are polish. Fix the first group before touching the rest. A long list means nothing without that order.
Ask of each finding: does this stop customers from finding or trusting the business? If yes, it goes first. If it only helps at the margin, it waits.
Be careful with audits that hand you a single score. A single score tells you nothing about whether to fix your categories or your title tags. The useful part of an audit is the ranked list and the reasoning.
What to fix first in this sample audit
For the sample HVAC company, the order would be: correct the Google Business Profile categories and services, fix the wrong phone number at the data aggregators, start a steady review request habit, then build separate service pages. Tracking comes in alongside, so you can see the effect of every change.
The profile and the phone number come first because they are quick and affect every other channel. Reviews are a habit, not a project: ask after each finished job. The service pages take longest, so they are scheduled once the quick fixes are done.
For the full process behind each step, use our local SEO checklist and the Google Business Profile optimization checklist.
What a real audit adds that a sample cannot
A real audit adds your actual numbers: how your profile appears for the searches that matter, who outranks you, what your Search Console data shows and where calls come from. It also compares you to the specific competitors in your map pack, not to a generic benchmark.
For a plumber in Tulsa or a dentist in Boise the findings would look different. The competitor set, the review volume needed to compete and the service pages that matter all depend on the market.
You can run a quick version yourself with our free local SEO audit tool, then decide whether to bring in help.
What happens after the audit
An audit is only useful if someone acts on it. After the audit, work the ranked list in order, re-check the profile and the map results after a few weeks, and keep the tracking running. Without that follow-up, an audit is a document, not a change.
Plan time for the fixes before you commission the audit. Many audits are read once and filed. Pick a person and a date for each of the top findings.
If you want us to run the audit and the fixes, see our local SEO audit service.
Frequently asked questions
What does a local SEO audit include?+
Is this SEO audit example a real business?+
How long does a local SEO audit take?+
Can I do a local SEO audit myself?+
What should I fix first after an audit?+
How often should I run a local SEO audit?+
Keep going
Sources & references
We audit your profile. Then we talk.
Book 30 minutes on video with the founder. We prepare your local SEO audit, go through it together, and you decide.
- 01You book your callPick a 30-minute slot in the founder’s calendar.
- 02We run your auditWe review your profile, your local opportunities and your competitors before the call.
- 03We go over it on videoWe walk you through the results and talk it over openly, whether we work together or not.